Improving access to Medicare-covered mental health benefits by recognizing state-licensed Marriage and Family Therapists (MFTs) by enacting S 562 (Wyden, D-OR, Barrasso, R-WY, and 10 other cosponsors) and HR 3662 (Gibson, R-NY, Thompson, D-CA, and 4 other cosponsors).
In order for a mental health service to be covered by Medicare, the service must be for the diagnosis and treatment of mental illness. In addition, the mental health service must be delivered by a “covered” practitioner who is legally authorized to perform that service under state law. (MFTs are licensed in every state.) The covered mental health professionals recognized by Medicare presently include psychiatrists, psychologists, mental health clinical nurse specialists and Clinical Social Workers (CSWs). Marriage and Family Therapists (MFTs) are not listed as Medicare-covered providers despite the fact that MFTs have education, training and practice rights equivalent to or greater than existing covered providers.
Several recent reports have indicated that limited access to mental health services is a serious problem in the Medicare program. This is particularly true in rural areas, which have historically had difficulty attracting and retaining health professionals. According to a recent Surgeon General’s report, 37% of seniors display symptoms of depression in a primary care environment. Equally striking is that fact that this depression often goes unrecognized and therefore untreated. The failure to treat depression often leads to more primary care visits and higher Medicare expenditures. The unavailability of qualified mental health professionals compounds the mental health crisis among the elderly population and increases the costs to the program.
Currently, the federal government recognizes five mental health disciplines as core mental health professionals. These are psychiatrists, psychologists, mental health clinical nurse specialists, clinical social workers and marriage and family therapists. Of these five groups, only marriage and family therapists are not recognized by Medicare.
The cost of adding MFTs to Medicare is modest. According to the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), the cost of adding both MFTs and Licensed Professional Counselors (LPCs) to the Medicare program would total $100 million during its first five years, and $400 million during ten years (CBO Score: 111th HR 3962, Sec. 1308). As the number of MFTs comprises about half of the total for the two professions combined, MFTs would account for roughly half of the cited costs. MFTs and LPCs would be paid at 75% of the rate provided to doctoral-minimum practitioners (physicians and clinical psychologists), the same 75% rate applicable to Social Workers, who also are masters-minimum professionals.
The U.S. Senate has twice approved legislation recognizing MFTs under Medicare (S 1 in 2003 and S 1932 in 2005), while the House also has twice approved such legislation (HR 3162 in 2007 and HR 3962 in 2009). Currently, there is bipartisan legislation in the House and Senate to expand Medicare to include MFTs as covered mental health professionals (S 562, HR 3662).
MFTs are legally authorized through state licensing laws to treat mental illness. MFTs are required to obtain a master’s degree in a mental health discipline and two years post-graduate supervised clinical experience, much like existing covered mental health providers, such as clinical social workers. This legislation will not change the mental health benefit or modify the MFT scope of practice, but will merely allow Medicare beneficiaries who need medically necessary covered mental health services to obtain those services from a marriage and family therapist. In essence, our proposal increases the pool of qualified providers that Medicare beneficiaries can choose from without change the services.
Significant shortages of mental health professionals continue to exist in many areas of the country, and rural counties suffer disproportionately. Federal government agencies also understand the valuable role MFTs play in increasing access to mental health services. The advisory committee to the Secretary of Health and Human Services recently encouraged inclusion of MFTs in the Medicare program.
The Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) further recognizes MFT’s participation in caring for underserved populations. One of HRSA’s responsibilities is to identify areas of the country with mental health shortages. The purpose of this designation is to identify communities with unmet mental health service needs and pursue opportunities to recruit qualified mental health professionals to those communities.
Ironically, HRSA counts marriage and family therapists among the “core” providers qualified to deliver necessary mental health services. The failure of the Medicare program to recognize marriage and family therapists leaves many elderly beneficiaries without access to care and creates a conflict in federal law. For example, in communities where the only mental health professional available is a marriage and family therapist, the Health Resources and Services Administration may count that MFT and consider the community well-served. In fact, the elderly of that community have no access to the MFT because Medicare will not recognize the provider. Consequently, the government doesn’t even know that there is an access problem because the two federal programs don’t have consistent criteria.
Marriage and family therapists are not seeking to expand the scope of mental health services covered by Medicare, nor are they seeking to expand their own scope of practice. Instead, MFTs are simply trying to correct an inequity that restricts beneficiaries’ access to a particular type of qualified mental health provider.
Furthermore, MFTs are not seeking higher payments for their services than are currently paid to clinical social workers. Under our proposal, marriage and family therapists would be paid at the same rate as clinical social workers (75% of the psychologists rate) for mental health services already covered by Medicare, which the MFT is legally authorized to provide in the state in which the service was delivered.
The importance of increasing the number of qualified Medicare mental health professionals by including MFTs is supported by many health organizations, including but not limited to AARP, the Depression and Bipolar Support Alliance, the National Council for Community Behavioral Healthcare, the National Rural Health Association and the California Primary Care Association.
Improve access to Medicare-covered mental health services by including marriage and family therapists among the list of providers who can deliver covered mental health services and pay for those services at the same rate as clinical social workers.
Contact James Morris, PhD, LMFT
Director of Professional and Public Affairs